Originally posted on
Tumblr
There is nothing in a story I care more about than the characters. Don’t get me wrong. I love beautiful prose and I enjoy a stellar plot. But I’ll trade it all for a truly wrenching character study.
What can I say? I love people. I’m fascinated by people. It’s people that matter to me, real or fiction.
Now, there’s much to be said for characters who are strong and noble and blah blah blah, but I’m much much more interested in their humanity than their virtues.
Seeing them at their best is great, but so is seeing them at their worst.
Show me the ugly side of who they are. I NEED IT.
Severus Snape, for example (light of my life) – There are plenty of “good” things to say about him. He’s intelligent, skilled, driven, dedicated, and passionate. Brave and strong. And I love those “good” parts of him, but I love his “bad” side, too. I love him prickly and petty and mean. I love him selfish and cruel.
He’s not a perfect person. But who is?
Real people are a mess, which I say with utmost fondness. I don’t love people for their good parts and good parts alone. I am not blind to their imperfections.
Real people are only human. Real people are worthy of love and respect and decency.
Fictional characters, silly as it might sound, deserve to be human, too. Their humanity is what often draws me to them in the first place, and seeing that humanity laid bare in a fanfic just does things to me.
Seeing the characters in their best form is find and dandy, and I won’t deny enjoying those portrayals or those stories.
But what touches me the most is seeing them at their worst. Seeing even our great heroes as mortal as the rest of us. I want to see them judgmental and temperamental and petty and mean. I want them cowardly and weak. If that’s who they are on the whole, or because they’re having a bad day and are lashing out or breaking down. Because even kind, patient people have moments of unkindness and impatience. No one is perfect.
We are all impacted by the world around us. By other people. By what has happened to us. By what weighs on us. It shapes us. And even when we fight against it, it shapes us in other ways.
I want Harry Potter’s bravery and his loyalty, but I also want his hot-headedness and impulsivity. I want this great hero screwing up because whatever great deeds he’s accomplished, he’s still a person. And he’s not immune to mistakes any more than the rest of us are.
I want Neville forgetful and insecure. Hermione overbearing and strict.
I want good people doing bad things.
I want their flaws on display. I want to revel in them.
I want more than the one trait to merely nod at to say “see? They’re not perfect.” I want to really see it. I want to feel it. I want to see those flaws impacting them and the people around them.
I want them down in the dirt. I want them flayed alive and bare to all, or at least bare to me. I want their humanity on ruthless display.
And then…this was not part of my original concept, but I’ll thank @phantomato for this one: seeing our villains as more than pure evil. More than weapons with which to destroy our beloved heroes. It’s both unsettling and fascinating to see these awful people be more than just their awful actions and awful traits. That there is goodness in them as much as there is anyone else.
Not feigning ignorance of those evil deeds and not forgiving them, really, but seeing them as more. Harry Potter is more than the savior, and Lord Voldemort is more than the bad guy.
I want their best and their worst. I want to see it all, so I can love them, all of them. I want to see all of them be loved by others; other readers and other characters.
There is comfort to be found there. In knowing that we don’t have to be perfect to be worthy of affection. There is comfort in understanding other people, and being ourselves understood.
And when an author makes these characters real…all I want to do is roll around in the dirt and bask in the filth and CELEBRATE all that these characters are.