Sometimes with fanfic I’ve thought about tagging how I see the characters identifying, but I figure if I don’t “show” it, I shouldn’t.
But I’ve been thinking about how reading fanfic taught me a lot about myself and it was all because of AO3 tags. I had no idea what demisexual even meant until I saw it tagged on a Supernatural fanfic.
And the fanfic itself didn’t necessarily teach me. The point of the story wasn’t to teach me anything, it was to tell the story of Cas and Dean (yes I’m a Destiel shipper.) But I was intrigued by the term and did my research.
I turned to Google. Then to Facebook groups. And all the while I kept following this fanfic series (The Writing on the Wall by DasMervin I highly recommend.) I had never really considered before that someone could be anything related to asexual and still be okay with sex. And the more I read of this fanfic and other people’s experiences, I decided that demisexual fit me best.
I no longer identify that way, but it was part of my journey.
In my teen years, I identified as bisexual, then pansexual, due to feeling pretty equally attracted to everyone. “That person is pretty, and so is that person, and so is that person!” Young Danni had no idea what aesthetic attraction was, okay? Think person is good looking = must be sexual attraction!
Wrong.
Think people are good looking? Check. Good with sex? Check. Sex-focused society? Check. But that does not sexual attraction make. I have never in my life experienced actual sexual attraction to anyone. Which I had never fully realized until I started exploring more about the asexual community. I learned about the Split-Attraction Model. I learned about being sex repulsed versus sex neutral versus sex favorable. I learned about demi and gray-ace.
I clung to the demisexual label longer than I think I should have. I think I knew better for a while. But I couldn’t fully reconcile wanting to have sex with a partner if I wasn’t at least demi. And even once I got there, I didn’t want to admit to not being actually sexually attracted to my partner. Eventually I moseyed over to the “asexual is the umbrella term so I’m just going to use that” camp before fully embracing the “nope, I’m definitely sex-favorable asexual.”
It was a long journey there. I’m 29 years old and only fully accepted and admitted it about a year ago. It fits me perfectly and it’s so freeing to me to have words to explain what I experience. My self-discovery journey has been a joyous one. Because I knew, even as a teenager, that something wasn’t quite right with how I felt, and that’s because the words I was using didn’t fit me. Having words for it helped me figure out where I am and how I feel. It helped me accept myself as I am and know that there is not (and never was) anything wrong with me at all.
Labels aren’t for everyone. They aren’t good, joyous, or helpful for everyone. And that’s fine. But for me it has been huge.
I’ve since read more fanfics with asexuality. None fitting my experience exactly. I’ve seen sex-repulsed or sex-neutral asexuality portrayed. I’ve probably read more demisexuality than anything.
I even read a Harry Potter fanfic where it wasn’t tagged, but in the story Harry identified himself as being bisexual and homo-romantic (Little Monkeys by Lilian, a Snarry fanfic) and it wasn’t me, but seeing the Split-Attraction Model in action had me grinning for quite some time after!
I still don’t know how to feel about tagging characters’ sexualities in fanfic (for my works, personally, if I don’t “showcase” it.) But I have to wonder…would it help someone like me? I think about how cool it would be for me even now to read a story where I knew one of the characters was just like me: sex favorable ace. If it’s never talked about, and no one would know without the tag because the character had a partner and enjoyed sex. Just thinking about it makes me happy!
And I think about other things that might not be as visible: bisexual or pansexual people in hetero-passing relationships. Or, much like what sent me on my journey, demisexual characters in relationships! To either see characters like you, living in ways that aren’t “obvious”, even if that part of your identity matters to you. Or to help people who might not realize there is a better label out there for them. Or even people who just don’t know about these terms, whether they would identify with them or not, still learning about them.
Maybe I’m overthinking it. But it does make me really happy when I see the characters tagged as asexual or bisexual or a plethora of other identities. So maybe I’ll do it myself one day. And maybe some people will roll their eyes. But maybe some people will give it a second look and wonder.